Seattle Indian Community -
| | |


Big Labors Anti Immigration Rumor Machine

Author : Vivek Wadhwa

Share With Your Friends

Add To My Favorite

TechCrunchThe passage of immigration reform by the Senate was a big stepforward. The bill is far from perfect, but goes a long way towardsolving Silicon Valley's talent shortage " and America'simmigrantexodus. But big hurdles lie ahead as anti-immigrantgroups regroup. Extreme elements of the right will be fighting toclose the borders while their counter parts on the left " BigLabor in particular " work to undermine high-skilled immigration.Why are trade unions that have practically no presence in thetechnology industry trying to make things difficult for SiliconValley? I really don't know. What I do know is that Big Labor'sthink tank Economic Policy Institute (EPI) is publishing onequestionable study after another to sabotage immigration reform.

It continues tograbnational headlinesfor research that claims that there isno tech-talent shortage. As stupid as this may seem to people inthe tech industry, EPI keeps repeating this " despite the factthat its evidence falls apart once respected economists review itsnon-peer-reviewed papers.

Facts don't usually get in the way ofpolitics, however.

It started with policy papers byRonHira, an associate professor at the Rochester Instituteof Technology.

Hira has made a career of repeating the words H1-Bsare taking American jobs away. He says that claims of a shortageare a ploy by Silicon Valley companies to bring wages down and toreplace Americans with foreign workers (Iam not kidding). Then cameNorm Matloff, a computer-science professor at UC Davis, whomadetheassertionthat foreign students have talent lesser than,or equal to, their American peers. Therefore,skilled-foreign-worker programs are causing an internal braindrain in the United States, he argues.

To top it all off, Rutgersprofessor Hal Salzman co-authored apaperfor EPI claiming that the U.S. graduates far more workers inscience, engineering, technology, and mathematics (STEM) than thetech industry needs and that foreign workers are discouraging Americans from pursuing technology careers.

How did they come tothese conclusions? Supposedly by analyzing salary data and speakingto their own students. As Salzman et al. write, The effect of thislarge supply of guestworkers can be seen in wages in I.T., whichhave remained flat, and are hovering around late 1990s levels inreal terms. Matloff says, flat wages are discouraging talentedU.S. workers with STEM degrees from pursuing graduate study or evencareers in the field. Hira says H1-B's are taking American jobsaway.

It is easy to cherry-pick misleading data. Jonathan Rothwelland Neil Ruiz of Brookings Institute did anobjectiveanalysisof salaries for the professions that get themost H1-B requests.Theyfoundthat wage growth in these was actually strongerthan the national average. They also found that H-1B workers arepaid more than U.S. native-born workers with a bachelor's degree($76,356 versus $67,301 in 2010) and even within the sameoccupation and industry for workers with similar experience.

Thecharthere(courtesy of Harvard Business Review) looks atthe salaries of 26- to 30-year-olds " the same age group asgraduating foreign students.

In fact,foreign workers get paid higher-than-average salaries. U.S. companies would not deal with the high political and financial costs of applying for visas if they could fill vacancies with equally qualified American workers. EPI claims that since STEM salary data has been stagnant, there is no unmet demand for high-tech workers.

Unfortunately, its analysis is based on bad data. For example, in the Salzman report, Figure I supposedly reports occupational wages for programmers from 1990 to 2011. But theCPS(their source) does not report these data before 2000, because of changes in how occupations were coded. CPS data show that almost one-fifth of contemporary computer programmers would not be classified in theolder system, so wage comparisons across the periods would beinaccurate. In fact, computer-programming wages haveincreasedin theperiod for which they are consistently defined.

Additionally, theclaim that EPI makes about guestworkers discouraging natives fromstudying technology was supposedly based on surveys by the NationalCenter for Education Statistics and from field work conducted overthe past decade by the author. There appears to be no crediblesurvey that validates this conclusion. The field work is alsoquestionable. In emails that I exchanged with Salzman, he would notprovide any further information. Rob Atkinson of The InformationTechnology Innovation Foundation also debunked the many myths inthe EPI research in paper titledTheReal Story on Guestworkers in the High-skill U.S. LaborMarket.

The report refutes each substantive EPI claim toshow that American students are dropping out of STEM majors at highrates; those that complete their majors are finding abundant workopportunities in their fields, and wages are growing for most IToccupations. In any case, demand for current IT skills is extremelyhigh, as engineering and computer majors have low unemploymentrates and earn higher wages than any other field of study,according to research from Georgetown University.

The reality isthat the country's most innovative region, Silicon Valley, isstarved for talent. Startups can't find workers with the skillsthey need, and larger companies have to set up centers offshore forthe same reasons. Big Labor and a handful of academics in theirivory towers can pontificate about how things should be. But allthey will achieve if they have their way is to choke off theability of Silicon Valley to create jobs " for them.

Link to article on TechCrunch’s website

About Author
Vivek Wadhwa is Vice President of Innovation and Research at Singularity University; Fellow, Arthur & Toni Rembe Rock Center for Corporate Governance, Stanford University; Director of Research at the Center for Entrepreneurship and Research Commercialization at the Pratt School of Engineering, Duke University; and distinguished visiting scholar, Halle Institute of Global Learning, Emory University. He is author of ”The Immigrant Exodus: Why America Is Losing the Global Race to Capture Entrepreneurial Talent”–which was named by The Economist as a Book of the Year of 2012.

Wadhwa oversees the academic programs at Singularity University, which educates a select group of leaders about the exponentially growing technologies that are soon going to change our world. These advances—in fields such as robotics, A.I., computing, synthetic biology, 3D printing, medicine, and nanomaterials—are making it possible for small teams to do what was once possible only for governments and large corporations to do: solve the grand challenges in education, water, food, shelter, health, and security.



Disclaimer: Please use this channel at your own discretion. These articles are contributed by our users. We are not responsible or liable for any problems related to the utilization of information of these articles.


View All Contributions

Premium Advertiser
Real Estate Brokers/Agents - Meryx, Dev Soor

This is an advertisement
Post an Article
Notify Me of New Articles

Become A Featured Contributor
Add Your Blog | Add Recipe | Add Article

More Article by Vivek Wadhwa

What the U.S. can learn from Indias move toward a cashless society
Why 2017 is the year of the bot
What Stephen Hawking gets right and wrong about the most dangerous time for our planet
These 6 new technology rules will govern our future
Fake news is just the beginning
View All Articles

Featured Contributors

Rima Arora

Tahmina Watson

Aayushi Manish
Aayushi Manish

Shruti Sadolkar

Ananya Kiran

Darshan Goswami
Darshan Goswami

Christine Dunbar

Anu Peshawaria

Vasudha Sharma
Vasudha Sharma

Latest Articles

Sunny Singh and Sonnalli Seygall are in love with their mothers! by Staff
Bhushan Kumar and Anees Bazmee come together for a love story starring Disha Patani and Kartik Aaryan by Staff
Sridhar Rangayan to be honoured at film festival in Spain by Staff
Hope by Mona Lamba
"I would like to direct a film someday" - Actor Rajesh Sharma by Staff
View All Articles